Walking vs Running: Best for Quick Weight Loss?

H

Hira Aslam

New Member
New Member
Trusted User
I have been trying to lose weight quickly and got confused between walking and running. some people say running is the best because it burns more calories and can help you lose fat faster.

On the other hand, kaafi log suggest walking as it is less intense and better for long term weight management. walking also has health benefits like improving cardiovascular strength and controlling blood sugar.

I am still unsure if switching to running will make a big difference for me. is it worth increasing the intensity, or should I stick to walking regularly?

I am a bit hesitant to start running because I have never done it before and worry it might be too intense for a beginner like me.

Kahin injuries na ho jaye, and honestly, I do not even have the right shoes for running. a friend of mine said I should aim for consistency rather than intensity.

But then, I read on Healtline that for weight loss with walking, you need to go at it for 150, 300 minutes a week, aur agar jaldi results chahte ho, toh 300+ minutes is preferable.

Walking seems like a more sustainable option, but I am keen to see faster results. winter is coming, which makes outdoor running sound less appealing.

If anyone here has tried both methods, what worked for you? did running ramp up your weight loss, or was walking enough to see changes? maybe there is a balance between both that I am missing? Your experiences could really help me decide.
 
starting with walking can be a great way to ease into fitness. i decided to add a simple 30-minute walk to my routine, and it really helped me feel less overwhelmed.
 
Have you considered mixing it up with high intensity interval training? It can burn a lot of calories in a short amount of time and helps maintain muscle mass while losing weight.
 
@Bilal Ahmed Switching to running might help with faster weight loss, lekin agar kisi ne running kabhi try nahi kiya, toh wo bilkul behtar hoga agar straightforward walking se shuru karein.

Running ki intensity beginners ke liye kabhi kabhi zyada challenge ho sakti hai, jo existing maslai se badhata hai jaise injuries. Bachche, guys, running shuru karte hue thore time lagta hai light warm up exercises karne mein.

Main bhi shuruat main sahi shoes nahi rakhta tha, is liye itna uncomfortable hota tha jab main bhaagta tha. Agar kisi ke shoes comfortable nahi hain, toh woh struggling karenge, aur yeh zaroori hai ke aap apne gear pe focus karin.

Kuch local groups ya fitness forums join karna behtar hota hai, kyun ke wahan log experiences share karte hain, aur behtar advice le sakte hain ankle support ki tarah additional help ke liye. local Facebook ya WhatsApp communities jaise health groups hai, wahan se insight lena bhi fayeda mand hai.
 
@Adeel Ahmed That is a good thought about high intensity interval training. i have noticed that it really ramps up calorie burn because you are pushing harder in shorter bursts.

It keeps your heart rate up, which is great for weight loss. I tried mixing HIIT into my routine last year, and it worked wonders for my fitness levels.

I paired it with some basic strength exercises, and I could feel my body responding quickly. Just remember that it can be intense, so starting gradually is key.

In my experience, incorporating HIIT can also help with muscle retention while losing fat. If someone is worried about losing muscle, this method really can help.

You can find lots of local HIIT classes or even join online sessions to get motivation from others. Check out Verywell Fit for practical tips on how to begin with HIIT if you are curious. It has some good introductory workouts that are helpful for beginners.
 
@Adeel Ahmed I have tried mixing in high intensity interval training with my regular routine, and the results were pretty noticeable. Initially, I felt it was tough, but once I got used to the intensity, I started to see changes in my body faster than with just steady state cardio.

One thing I found really helpful was using local fitness apps offering quick HIIT workouts. These workouts usually only take around 20-30 minutes, so I could easily fit them into my day without taking too much time.

The key for me was to focus on maintaining form while pushing through those bursts of exertion. I initially struggled with that, but over time, I found my stamina increased significantly, and I felt stronger overall.

You might want to check out local classes or online videos to get started if you are curious about HIIT. They really help in understanding the movements and keeping the motivation up.
 
@Sehrish Ali It is true that switching to running can boost weight loss, especially if you take it slow at first. a helpful tip to ease into it is setting specific intervals.

For example, start with a one minute run followed by two minutes of walking, and repeat this for 20-30 minutes. This approach really helps your body adapt to the intensity gradually.

I did something similar in the beginning when I switched from walking to running, and it made a huge difference for me. Plus, you can adjust the intervals as you get stronger.

and as you get comfortable, you can also keep track of your progress through apps like Strava or Runkeeper. They give you a clear picture of how your running is improving and can keep you motivated!
 
I get the hesitation about running, especially if you are just starting out. It can be pretty intense, and having the right shoes definitely makes a difference.
 
@Maryam Ahmed High intensity interval training really has a unique way of maximizing calorie burn, kyun kay wo short bursts of effort keep your body guessing and constantly challenge your stamina.

It is definitely not just about the time spent working out but the intensity of the effort. Main khud bhi jab HIIT karti thi, toh mujhe ye feel hota tha ke main zyada calories burn kar rahi thi compared to just steady running.

Plus, it tends to boost your metabolism for hours after the workout, which is an added bonus. have you tried mixing any strength training with your HIIT?

combining both can really enhance muscle retention while burning fat. It keeps things interesting as well, and I have noticed that variety keeps me more motivated to stick with my workouts in the long run.
 
@Noor Fatima I like the idea of starting with intervals to ease into running. It is a smart way to gradually build up stamina and avoid injury, especially for beginners.

another angle to consider is incorporating strength training into your routine. It can complement your running by improving muscle strength, which helps with form and efficiency.

I started adding some basic bodyweight exercises after my runs, and I noticed it not only helped with my running but also boosted my overall fitness level.

There are plenty of exercises you can do at home or even at the gym, like squats or lunges. This combination can make your running sessions more effective while preventing burnout. If you have not tried it yet, maybe it is worth considering!
 
@Salman Tariq Bilkul, sahi kaha apne, shoes ka khayal rakhna toh bohot zaroori hai. Lekin kuch log sochte hain ke sirf achi shoes se marathon runner ban jate hain.

Running start karna hai toh shoes ka budget bana lo, warna pehli dafa run kar ke aise lagay ga jaise kisi ne hamesha ke liye gym khol diya ho.

Aray, ek baat toh hai, jab main pehli dafa run karne gayi thi, toh ek dost ne keh diya tha ke achi shoes le lo.

Maine fancy dikhti shoes le li thi, lekin isme daud kar sirf apni thakawat ka ahsas hota tha. Toh jo bhi shoes lo, ensure kar lo ke wo comfy hon, nahi toh sirf bura mashwara milega.

Apne pace pe dhyan dena bhi zaroori hai, nahi toh sirf shoes ka kya faida agar aapki stamina ki chutti ho gayi ho. soch rahi thi, shayad run ke pehle chai ka shot bhi zaroori hai!
 
@Rabia Ahmed Just having good shoes is not the only factor in becoming a successful runner. While they are definitely important, form, conditioning, and overall fitness play huge roles too.

Many beginners focus only on shoe quality and neglect these other aspects. i have seen people buy the most expensive shoes but they still struggle because they do not pay attention to their running technique or cardio endurance.

Investing in a trainer or joining a running group can be really beneficial, especially in the beginning. Local clubs often help with everything from drills to pace settings, turning a tough experience into an enjoyable routine. So it is not just about the gear you start with, but also the knowledge and support you gather along the way.
 
@Anum Khan Hmm, acha hai na, conditioning aur form ka sochna, lekin shoes pe akele zyada focus karna bhi ek tareeqa hai. Lagta hai ap ne sab kuch running magazine se seekh liya hai jahan sirf expert tips chalte hain!

Lekin actually, yeh toh important hai ke aapki body ki adaptability bhi dekhi jaye. agar ek person thora bhaag kar dekhe aur phir footpath pe hi gir jaye, toh uski conditioning ka kya faida?

Mujhe yaad hai, jab main ne pehli dafa running shuru ki thi, toh mujhe bhi yeh lagta tha ke sab kuch perfect hona chahiye.

Lekin jab tak apki body khud ko adjust nahi karti, tab tak sirf theory ka kya? Baki sab aacha, lekin real world practice hi asal masla solve karti hai.

Aur haan, agar shoes itne hi zaroori hote, toh marathons mein kitne log bina badi shoes ke chale jaate. Bas, aapko apne pair ka bhi khayal rakhna chahiye. Shoes bechain nahi, conditioning pe focus karna chahiye!
 
@Rabia Ahmed focusing on shoes alone does not address the other crucial aspects of running, like form and overall fitness levels. While good footwear undoubtedly supports performance, they cannot fix poor running technique or a lack of conditioning.

If you only concentrate on shoes and ignore these fundamentals, it can lead to injuries or burnout. Last year, I saw someone at a running group purchase high end shoes but still struggle significantly with their stamina during a practice run.

strengthening your core and improving your cardiovascular health should be part of the fitness plan too. There are various workouts available online or through local gyms and groups that can help focus on building these areas alongside running. consider integrating those into the routine rather than relying solely on shoe quality.
 
@Anum Tariq Wo jo apne HIIT ka zikr kiya, wo sahi baat hai. Main jab pehli dafa HIIT kar rahi thi, toh mujhe her workout ke end pe stamina ka fark mehsoos hua.

Har session ek naya challenge lagta tha, aur mujhe us excitement se pyaas mil rahi thi. Mujhe yaad hai main ek Facebook group join kiya tha jo local fitness sessions host karta tha.

Woh support aur motivation group ki wajha se tha, kyun kay sab log mil kar push karte hain aur wo thakawat manageable lagti hai. Apni serious fitness journey mein ye group ka hissa hona bohot help kar raha hai.
 
@Anum Khan Shoes ki importance ka mujhe pata hai, lekin ab jab apne baat ki conditioning aur form ki, toh main thora confused ho gaya hoon.

Mujhe ye samajh nahi aata ke shuruat kaise karun. Mera fitness routine thora unstable hai, aur ab tak sirf walking kiya hai. Kya aapke paas koi specific tips hain in cheezon ko improve karne ke liye?

Main acha shoes le kar bhi running se pehle workout aur conditioning par focus karna chahta hoon, lekin kahan se shuru karun ye nahi samajh aa raha. Mujhe lagta hai ke kisi local group ya community ka hissa rehna bhi help karega. Kya apko koi recommendations hain is bare mein?
 
I started with walking too, thinking it was a good way to get into fitness. I walked 30 minutes a day, which felt manageable at first. However, when I tried to increase my pace too quickly, it led to a knee issue that sidelined me for a bit.
 
Back
Top